PBR Plumbing vs Martin & Co Plumbing: which fits your roofing & gutter job?
Both of these Perth outfits show up as genuine alternatives for roofing and gutter plumbing, but they earn their reputations in different corners of the trade. PBR Plumbing has a bigger track record and a name for tackling messy, complex jobs, while Martin & Co Plumbing is a smaller, newer-reviewed team known for speed and tidy site work. Here's how they stack up, based on our methodology.
The differences that matter
- Track record on complex jobs. PBR Plumbing's 81 reviews include mentions of handling multi-day and complex jobs that others turned away, which matters more for tricky roof or gutter faults than a routine callout.
- Review volume and confidence. PBR Plumbing's composite score carries low confidence despite the higher number (82.5), while Martin & Co Plumbing's lower score (78.2) comes with high confidence from a smaller but consistent 20-review base.
- Documentation habits. PBR Plumbing is specifically praised for photo documentation of work, useful for insurance claims or proving a gutter or roof fix was done properly.
- Specialty overlap. Martin & Co Plumbing's named strengths lean toward hot water systems and gas work, with no roofing or gutter specialty called out, whereas PBR Plumbing's praise centers on emergency leaks and complex jobs that align more directly with roof and gutter failures.
- Speed vs depth. Martin & Co Plumbing wins on same-week booking and fast turnaround, while PBR Plumbing leans on same-day emergency response and named technicians who've handled harder cases.
Side by side
- Google rating
- PBR Plumbing: 4.8 (81 reviews)
- Martin & Co Plumbing: 5 (20 reviews)
- Services
- PBR Plumbing: new home construction plumbing, bathroom renovation plumbing, roofing and gutters, emergency plumbing
- Martin & Co Plumbing: roofing and gutters, hot water systems, plumber, gas installation service
- Best for
- PBR Plumbing: Complex or long-running roof leak diagnosis and multi-day gutter repairs
- Martin & Co Plumbing: Straightforward gutter fixes needing fast scheduling and a tidy finish
- Specialty fit for roofing & gutter
- PBR Plumbing: Emergency leak response and documented complex repairs
- Martin & Co Plumbing: General plumbing with hot water/gas focus, less evidence of roofing-specific work
- Verification
- PBR Plumbing: Google-verified
- Martin & Co Plumbing: Google-verified
- Composite score
- PBR Plumbing: 83
- Martin & Co Plumbing: 78
What reviewers say
PBR Plumbing
PBR Plumbing has earned a 4.8-star rating across 81 reviews, with 94% five-star marks. Customers consistently praise the team's punctuality, professionalism, and willingness to document work with photos and clear communication. Reviewers name Aiden, Mike, Jack, Glynn, and owner Paul as capable technicians who handle everything from emergency leaks to complex multi-day jobs, often arriving same-day and explaining their process clearly.
Martin & Co Plumbing
Reviewers consistently report quick response times and on-time arrival, with teams arriving calm and polished. Work stays clean, staff are approachable, and jobs move fast. One reviewer noted the technician could have explained tap durability upfront, but overall clients leave satisfied and willing to return.
Named staff including Callum, Jamie, Josh, Liam, and Rob appear regularly in feedback. Hot water system installations and electrical work alongside plumbing are mentioned as handled professionally. The team keeps sites tidy during jobs and communicates what is happening as they work.
Which should you pick?
Pick PBR Plumbing if
- Your roof or gutter issue is a hard-to-diagnose leak or has already stumped another plumber
- You want photo-documented proof of the work for insurance or landlord records
- You need same-day emergency response for active water damage
Pick Martin & Co Plumbing if
- You want a fast, same-week booking for a straightforward gutter job
- You value a clean job site and clear updates over deep specialization
- You're also considering bundling in hot water or gas work at the same visit
Verdict
Pick based on how complicated your roof or gutter problem is, not the headline score. PBR Plumbing has built its name on messier, harder jobs and backs it up with photo documentation, which counts for more when a leak has been misdiagnosed before or the damage is extensive. Martin & Co Plumbing is a safer bet for a routine gutter repair where speed and a tidy crew matter most, though its high-confidence score reflects a much smaller sample and no called-out roofing specialty. For anything beyond a simple fix, PBR Plumbing's track record on complex work makes it the stronger match.
Can't decide which plumber to choose?
Describe your job once and compare quotes from suitable plumber in Perth metro.
Enquiries from this site's forms may be shared with partner providers who perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Rankings and scores here are based solely on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.
Frequently asked questions
- Which business has more experience specifically with roofing and gutter plumbing?
- Neither lists it as a named specialty, but PBR Plumbing's praise for handling complex jobs and emergency leaks lines up more closely with typical roof and gutter failures than Martin & Co Plumbing's hot water and gas focus.
- Is Martin & Co Plumbing's perfect 5-star rating more reliable than PBR Plumbing's 4.8?
- It's based on 20 reviews versus PBR Plumbing's 81, so PBR Plumbing's rating rests on a larger sample even though its composite confidence is marked low.
- Who responds faster in an emergency?
- PBR Plumbing is specifically praised for same-day emergency response, while Martin & Co Plumbing is praised for same-week booking and on-time arrival, a slightly different speed promise.